Personal experience with various brands, I think you can safely store them. But how long you gonna use that printer anyway??
Cartriges might be a bit different than bottled ink, but I refilled old cartriges too. If you know of people that had problems it could be the type of cartrig? I think the HPs I broke open and refilled used a packed cotton type packing to hold the ink. The 4100 cannon used more of a packed felt I think, then had a hard felt tip at the bottom of the cartrig to let the ink out, sort of like a filter.
Xerox M750 and I850 Cannon have the ink in a side of the cartrig in bulk liqiud, then it flows through a foam packing type material. Sort of like foamrubber.
The HP black tanks don't seem to have an actual packing inside, the ink is in liquid volume, when empty the tank is clear and you can see inside.
I think all the above is correct, though I haven't been refilling anything other than the Cannon I850 much lattely. Using it for almost everything now.
Perhaps durring storage the packing materials breakdown on some cartriges?? Maybe the foam rubber or cotton will lose fine particales as it ages or something and cause the jets to clog? I never had that problem myself though. Only time I have had any problems with print head clogging up is when an open cartrig sits for a long time unused. The ink dries out, but nearly always I soak the printhead in distilled alcohaul for while and the clog disolves and the head works like new. I don't use rubbing alcohaul, I use distilled pharmacy $6 a bottle alcohaul! i use it to manually clean the VCR heads also, especialy on the Beta VCR.
Otherwise I have used my old cartriges though for what seems like forever, just keep replacing the ink. I also try not to run them dry, I think that can burn out the heads.
I think the oldest HP cartrig is about 1 1/2 years old and still works ok. The Xerox printer died in less than a year and the I850 I only had a few months, so I cannot truely say how long or well those tanks store for real long times. The Xerox problem is a printer problem not ink or printhead related. Bad internal cable and needs to be RMA'd, just can't find the receipt. (should have registered that one)
The cannon 4100 I had for many years never had clogged jet problems either, and some of those cartriges were really old! Print heads would burn out over time it seamed, sometimes I would turn on the printer and it just beep and flash error message with the LEDS. Pop in new head and all was well.
Sometimes I would get banding on that printer, but I got that even when I was first buying real Cannon cartiges brand new as they were needed! It did not get any worse after I started refilling the empties forever!
One thing I should say though is when I say I never had problems, I mean nothing I don't have with a brand new cartrig! Any cartrig or print head in all the printers I have had will clog a jet after it sits unused for awhile, then I get banding till I clean it. But that happens with all of them. Buy a cartrig at Wallmart and install today, don't print again till next friday and I'll get few few little bands and have to clean the head. The 3 HP printers I have had have been the worst for that! A 632, and 2 656C Hp printers, all use the same cartrig number and all clog alittle if you go a week or two with no printing, even when using brand new HP cartriges! Manytimes just running the clean head printer utility works, sometimes I clean them manaully.
So based on my personal experince over many years and several brands, I would have to say it's as safe to store "most" cartriges for long periods as it is to buy new ones as needed
May I borrow your disclaimer FP? Just my opion.
Another thought to think is the printer life! How long you gonna use this printer?? Will the next one use the same catriges? My Xerox died in just a few months, it is no longer available to buy. If I had stored up lots of cartriges (I did a few) then I am stuck with stuff I can't use now! Because I do the refilling and like to travel durring the summer, I bought 3 or 4 of each cartirg for the Xerox last year that still are not opened. Just so the wife would have plenty of ink while I was gone. Now I have those and no use for them! I refilled the old ones and used them, never opened the spares. About $75 just sitting there!
Cost of printers are dropping! That's what I look at too. These 2 I850s I bought at Sams club for about $150 each just a month or 2 ago. Prices already dropped $20-$30. NOWHERE else could I find them for less than the $200 suggested retail then, now Bestbuy has them like $170 last I was there.
So if your planning to store cartriges for 2 years or more, will you actually use them?
Looks like I'm gonna lose my butt on the spare I850 I bought. By the time I actually use it I will probably be able to buy it for $100.
FP, another reason I recomend to all my freinds to refill instead of buying cartriges is the cost of printers! Most everyone I know personally has a cheapo lexmark or HP $50 or less Wallmart Printer.
Everyone worries about damaging the printers. But really, how many times do you refill before you can buy a new printer and still come out ahead?? Locally we either have to refill or buy HP $30 -$40 cartriges at Wally World. Mail order generics or factory refilled for about $12-$15. So if you refill 5 times then had to buy a new printer you still saved $8 or a heck of alot more! If you refilled only Twice then had to buy a new printer you still saved $10-$20 over the cost of buying new HP cartriges, plus you get the new cartrig that comes with a new printer! So far none of us have had to buy new printers because of any problems refilling, but that is something to think about!
Now when we are talking these Cannon I850 $170 printers, that's a bit different
I truely do consider a $50 printer to be a throw away when you look at cartrig costs (even generics) compared to nearly free refills!!